top of page
Safewize-workplace-mental-health.png

8.Poor Workplace Relationships is a Psychosocial Hazard: What It Is, Why It Matters, and How Australian Businesses Manage It

Aug 28
7 min read

What is poor workplace relationships as a psychosocial hazard in Australian workplaces?

Poor workplace relationships is a recognised psychosocial hazard under the Managing Psychosocial Hazards at Work Code of Practice 2024. It occurs when conflict, hostility, exclusion or dysfunction in team relationships creates a social environment that damages workers' psychological health. Sustained poor workplace relationships cause stress, anxiety, disengagement and psychological injury. Under the WHS Act 2011, businesses must assess and control this hazard using the hierarchy of controls.


poor workplace relationships an lead to psychosocial hazards

What Is Poor Workplace Relationships?

Poor workplace relationships occurs when the social environment of a workplace — the way people interact, treat each other and relate day-to-day — is consistently hostile, conflicted, exclusionary or dysfunctional in ways that cause psychological harm.


This is distinct from bullying, which involves repeated unreasonable behaviour directed at a specific person. Poor workplace relationships is broader — it includes team-level dysfunction, persistent interpersonal conflict between colleagues, exclusionary cultures, and workplaces where the social atmosphere is chronically tense, distrustful or demoralising even without a specific perpetrator and target.


A worker does not need to be the direct subject of conflict to be harmed by poor workplace relationships. Witnessing conflict, navigating a tense team environment, or working in a culture of gossip, cliques and exclusion all cause measurable psychological harm — even when the individual is not directly targeted.


The SafeWize Psychosocial Hazard Register rates poor workplace relationships at 3 — Medium inherent risk in most workplaces, rising to 4 — High in environments with high-pressure team dynamics, high staff turnover, significant power differentials, or a history of unresolved conflict. Safe Work Australia recognises workplace relationships as a core psychosocial hazard category, and Beyond Blue offers practical tools for building psychologically safe team environments.



What Poor Workplace Relationships Looks Like

Persistent interpersonal conflict: Two team members who are in ongoing unresolved conflict, creating a team environment where everyone else manages around their dynamic.


Exclusionary culture: A long-term group of workers who exclude newer or different team members from social events, information sharing and informal communication.


Gossip and rumour: A workplace culture where information about colleagues is shared informally in ways that damage reputations and create distrust.


Team fragmentation: A team that has split into factions, with different groups aligned to different managers, projects or personalities — creating competing loyalties and communication breakdowns.


Passive-aggressive dynamics: A team where conflict is never raised directly but is expressed through withholding information, undermining work, or creating friction in small ways that are individually deniable.


Social isolation of individuals: A worker who is not included in team conversations, left out of group lunches, and not copied on relevant emails — without this rising to the level of formal bullying.


Why Poor Workplace Relationships Cause Harm

Humans are social beings. The quality of our relationships at work has a direct impact on psychological wellbeing — not just because we spend a lot of time at work, but because social connection and belonging are fundamental psychological needs.


A worker in a hostile or dysfunctional team environment is in a chronic state of social threat — hypervigilant to interpersonal cues, spending cognitive energy managing relationships rather than doing the work, and unable to access the social support that buffers against other workplace stressors.


The cumulative effect is significant. Poor workplace relationships is consistently associated with higher rates of anxiety, depression and psychological injury. It also drives absenteeism, presenteeism and turnover — workers in dysfunctional teams leave when they can and disengage when they cannot.


Three Workplaces Managing Poor Workplace Relationships

Case Study 1 — A Veterinary Clinic

A veterinary clinic has six staff — two vets, two vet nurses and two receptionists. Over time a split has developed between the two vet nurses, who have been with the clinic for years, and the receptionists, who are newer. The nurses refer to the reception area as "their side" and regularly make comments in earshot of the receptionists that imply they are less important to the clinic. The receptionists have stopped asking questions they need answered, instead trying to work things out themselves to avoid the interaction. Client service is starting to suffer because information is not being communicated between the front desk and the clinical team.


The hazard: Team fragmentation with an exclusionary culture that has developed between established and newer staff, with indirect expressions of hierarchy that are demoralising receptionists and creating communication breakdowns affecting client care.


The control applied — Level 4 Engineering: The clinic principal introduces a weekly five-minute all-staff stand-up at the start of each day — mandatory, brief, structured around three questions: what is on today, what do we need from each other, and is there anything blocking anyone. The format requires cross-team communication as part of the daily structure. A shared digital noticeboard is introduced for patient and client information, removing the informal gatekeeping of information between teams. The communication flows are engineered to require interaction, rather than leaving it to goodwill.


Residual risk: Low (2) — the structural division is not immediately resolved, but the daily requirement for cross-team communication breaks down the informal barrier over time.


Case Study 2 — A Construction Site Office

A construction company's site office has four project managers who have worked together for three years. Two of them — a senior project manager and a contracts administrator — had a significant professional disagreement 18 months ago that was never formally resolved. The tension between them is visible to the whole office. Junior staff avoid asking either of them questions when the other is present. In a recent project handover, information was not passed on between them and the client noticed. The site manager has been aware of the tension but has avoided addressing it because "they're both good at their jobs."


The hazard: Persistent unresolved interpersonal conflict between two senior staff members that is affecting the whole team's psychological environment and creating operational risk.


The control applied — Level 3 Isolation: The site manager arranges a structured mediation session with an external HR mediator — the two staff members meet with the mediator separately and then together to work through the original disagreement and agree on working norms. While the mediation process is underway, project responsibilities are restructured so the two have minimal direct interdependencies. Following mediation, the working relationship protocols are documented and signed by both parties.


Residual risk: Low (2) — the source conflict is addressed directly rather than worked around.


Case Study 3 — A Childcare Centre

A childcare centre has a close-knit team of nine educators who have worked together for several years. When a new educator joins — younger, differently trained and from a different cultural background — she finds herself consistently excluded from informal conversations, not included in the group chat the other educators use, and given the least desirable duties during the first three months. She does not raise it formally because she is on probation and worried about job security. She starts calling in sick on days when she knows a particular group of colleagues will be working.


The hazard: Exclusionary culture targeting a newer worker, compounded by a power dynamic (probationary employment) that prevents the worker from raising the concern. The exclusion does not rise to the legal definition of bullying but is causing clear psychological harm and attendance impact.


The control applied — Level 1 Elimination + Level 5 Administrative: The centre director introduces an inclusion protocol as part of the onboarding process — a named "welcome buddy" for every new worker for the first three months, an explicit expectation that all staff are included in team communication channels, and a duty rotation system that distributes preferred and less preferred duties fairly across the team. SOP-01 (Workplace Behaviour Standards) and SOP-05 (Workplace Inclusion and Respect) are activated, communicated to the whole team and acknowledged in writing. The exclusionary conditions are eliminated from the structural onboarding model.


Residual risk: Very Low (1) — the new worker now has a named support person, inclusion is a documented expectation, and duty allocation is fair by design.


The Hierarchy of Controls Applied to Poor Workplace Relationships


L1 — Eliminate: Redesign team structures to reduce friction points. Build inclusion into onboarding by design. Remove conditions that structurally enable exclusion or fragmentation.


L2 — Substitute: Replace adversarial performance frameworks with collaborative ones. Substitute informal communication channels that enable exclusion with structured, accessible team communication.


L3 — Isolate: Physically or operationally separate workers in active conflict — adjusted rosters, seating or team assignments — while formal resolution processes are underway.


L4 — Engineering: Engineer interaction into the work structure. Daily stand-ups, shared information systems, cross-team project structures and duty rotation systems that require collaboration rather than leaving it to goodwill.


L5 — Administrative: Implement SOP-01 (Workplace Behaviour Standards), SOP-03 (Conflict Resolution), SOP-04 (Respectful Communication) and SOP-05 (Workplace Inclusion and Respect). Train managers in early identification of conflict and how to intervene before it becomes entrenched. Introduce team agreements where norms are co-created and documented.


L6 — Personal Support: EAP available. Mediation support for interpersonal disputes. Wellbeing check-ins for workers in teams with known relationship difficulties.



poor workplace relationships

What You Need to Document

Your risk assessment for poor workplace relationships must include:

  • How the hazard presents in your workplace — the nature and source of relationship difficulties

  • Pre-control risk rating

  • Controls applied at each hierarchy level

  • Post-control risk rating

  • Responsible person, monitoring method and review date



Frequently Asked Questions


What is poor workplace relationships as a psychosocial hazard?


Poor workplace relationships is a recognised psychosocial hazard under the Code of Practice 2024. It occurs when conflict, hostility, exclusion or dysfunction in team relationships creates a social environment that damages psychological health. It is broader than bullying — it includes team-level dysfunction, persistent conflict, exclusionary cultures and toxic team dynamics even without a specific perpetrator and target.


What is the difference between poor workplace relationships and bullying?


Bullying involves repeated, unreasonable behaviour directed at a specific person that creates risk to their psychological health. Poor workplace relationships is broader — it includes team dysfunction, persistent conflict between colleagues, exclusionary cultures and demoralising social environments that affect multiple workers, even when no single person is the target of specific repeated behaviour. Both are recognised psychosocial hazards under the Code of Practice 2024.


Is a toxic workplace culture a psychosocial hazard?


Yes. A workplace culture characterised by chronic conflict, exclusion, gossip, distrust or dysfunction creates the conditions for poor workplace relationships, which is a recognised psychosocial hazard under the WHS Act 2011 and Code of Practice 2024. Businesses are required to identify and control this hazard — a "that's just how we are" response does not satisfy the legal obligation.


How do you improve workplace relationships without making it worse?


The most effective approaches address the structural conditions that enable poor relationships rather than focusing solely on the individuals involved. Engineering interaction into work structures, building inclusion protocols into onboarding, making conflict resolution pathways visible and safe, and training managers to intervene early are all more effective than reactive individual interventions after relationships have broken down.


Continue the series:


SafeWize provides practical psychosocial hazard compliance tools for Australian small and medium businesses. This guide is for educational purposes and does not constitute legal advice. Always confirm requirements with your applicable state or territory WHS regulator.

 
 
 

Comments


bottom of page